We did not buy extra papers this past weekend because there was just 1 coupon insert and it was cheaper for us to buy the inserts themselves instead of extra papers (our paper costs $2).
We just bought 5 P&G inserts for $4 including shipping on eBay. Hooray!
Go here to view all the P&G inserts on eBay.
*You are actually paying the seller for their time to clip the coupons, just like a clipping service. You are not technically paying for the coupons.*
There are many different coupon sellers, some selling 1 insert, some selling 3, some selling 5 and we even saw one listing for 50 of them! Be sure to check the price they are charging for shipping when you are making your buying decision.
Go here to view the seller we purchased from. At the time of writing, she still had sets of 5 available for $4 with free shipping.